Revise from feedback

Upload your draft chapter and your supervisor's comments, and Anara classifies each comment by what it requires and drafts a revision plan, with library citations where the argument needs support. Use it when a growing feedback list is standing between you and your next writing session.

Prompt

A PhD student in wound care nursing works through a supervisor's annotated draft.

I'm revising my PhD thesis chapter on compression therapy adherence in VLU nursing. Attached are two documents: my draft chapter and my supervisor's feedback PDF.

Read both. For each supervisor comment, do the following:
1. State what kind of change it requires: new citation, argument restructure, writing clarity, or factual check.
2. Draft a specific revision action for that comment.
3. If the comment requires a new citation, search my library and name the best supporting passage.

Present the output as a numbered list matching the order of the comments. Flag any comment you cannot resolve from my current library so I know where I need to find new literature.

What to add to your library

• Required: your draft chapter, in your library or attached to the chat.
• Required: the supervisor's feedback, as a track-changes PDF or separate document.
• Optional: the folder of papers for this chapter, searched for citation support.
• Optional: your submission date and the chapter's role in the dissertation, to prioritize structural comments.

What you get

• Each comment matched to a change type and a specific revision action.
• Named library passages with citations for comments that need evidence.
• Outlines for structural changes, and flags where your library cannot cover a gap.

Follow-ups

Draft the response letter.

Draft a response letter addressing each comment from the list. For each one, summarize the change I made and explain the reasoning. Keep the tone collaborative. Number the responses to match the original comment list.

Place newly imported papers.

I've imported three new papers on compression adherence. Search them and suggest where in the chapter they can be cited to address the supervisor's comment about insufficient evidence on patient self-management.

Tips

• Number the comments before uploading. For track-changes PDFs, ask Anara to list all comments first.
• Keep "flag any comment you cannot resolve from my current library" in the prompt to avoid invented citations.
• "Clarify this" sometimes means "I disagree." Reclassify any real challenge the plan treats as a clarity edit.
• Run the claim-verification workflow on heavily rewritten paragraphs before sending the chapter back.